|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
What has just been approved reinforces the impression that this is a desperate attempt to campaign on an issue that needed solutions long ago—not last-minute headlines.
Parliament’s Permanent Deputation has ratified one of the housing decrees and rejected the one proposing indefinite rental contracts. The outlet reports that the vote comes after the Government reapproved texts previously rejected by Congress, and on the eve of the election campaign.
The timing alone does not prove an electoral motive. But politically, my interpretation is clear: after eight years in power, presenting yet another emergency intervention as the major answer to the housing crisis has very little credibility.
They have had time to introduce reforms, seek agreements and build a stable housing policy. I do not accept that they should now present themselves as newcomers to a problem for which they have held responsibility for years.
You Cannot Govern Through Permanent Emergency Measures
Housing requires long-term planning. It needs available land, renovation, construction, an adequate public housing stock and rules that allow people to make decisions with confidence.
A decree can address a specific emergency. What it cannot do is replace a sustained policy pursued over many years.
That is why I find it particularly questionable that the debate is once again focused on restricting, extending and intervening in contracts, while the fundamental question remains unchanged: how do we make more homes available where people need to live?
Announcing protection is easy. Designing a system that protects people without discouraging supply requires considerably more work—and less propaganda.
Protecting Tenants Should Not Mean Pitting Them Against Landlords
I refuse to accept that this debate must be framed as a battle between landlords and tenants.
Tenants need stability, reasonable terms and protection against abuse. People who put a property on the rental market need to receive the agreed rent, protect their property and have effective remedies when a contract is breached.
Both are compatible. In fact, they should be inseparable.
The report describes measures such as extending protection against certain evictions until 2030 and extraordinary extensions for certain rental contracts. It also mentions compensation for landlords and mechanisms for public authorities to intervene. The question is not simply what the legislation promises, but whether those mechanisms will work promptly, adequately and effectively.
Vulnerability deserves a public response. But that response should not depend on an individual landlord’s financial resources, patience or assets.
If public authorities want to guarantee alternative accommodation, they must take responsibility by providing resources and solutions—not simply prolong a situation that someone else has to bear.
The Risk Is Protecting Those Already Renting While Making It Harder for Everyone Else to Get In
Rental policy cannot be assessed solely by looking at existing contracts. We must also consider people still searching for a home.
What happens to the young person trying to move out of their parents’ home? The family that needs to relocate? Someone moving to another city for work?
My concern is that conditions perceived as increasingly uncertain may lead some landlords to withdraw their properties from the rental market or demand stronger guarantees. That does not mean every landlord will do so, nor that a single regulation explains the performance of the entire market. It means this risk must be assessed seriously, rather than dismissed because it is inconvenient for the political narrative.
The report specifically includes warnings from the sector about declining supply. Those warnings deserve analysis and scrutiny—not automatic dismissal.
If bringing homes onto the market becomes more difficult, people trying to find somewhere to live may end up suffering the consequences of measures supposedly introduced on their behalf.
Not Everything Is Justified by Calling It “Social”
According to the report, the decree also includes tax incentives, financing and measures relating to public and affordable housing. I will not reject a useful initiative simply because it comes from a Government I disagree with.
But neither will I endorse an entire policy because it contains some defensible measures.
Support for homebuyers, for example, must be assessed alongside the capacity to increase supply. Easier access to financing may help certain buyers; on its own, it does not create new homes.
And expanding public housing requires delivery, deadlines and verifiable results. Announcements are not enough.
Eight Years Later, It Is Time for Accountability
As a real estate agent, I reject an approach that repeatedly places landlords and the private market at the centre of the blame, while political responsibility seems to disappear amid announcements and new restrictions.
I do not attribute every housing problem to a single administration: national, regional and local authorities all have responsibilities. But that complexity cannot become an excuse for the Government to avoid scrutiny of its own eight-year record.
My assessment is deeply negative. I believe its approach has contributed to undermining confidence and the functioning of the market, rather than creating the conditions needed to expand it and improve access.
That is why I see this last-minute operation as an attempt to campaign on housing—not the change of direction we need.
Spain needs more homes, greater legal certainty and social protection that works. Not another election campaign disguised as a housing solution.







